Cognitive coherence relations and hypertext: from cinematic patterns to scholarly discourse

ABSTRACT

In previous work we argued that cinematic language may provide insights into the construction of narrative coherence in hypertext, and we identified in the shot juxtaposition of rhetorical patterns the source of coherence for cinematic discourse. Here we deepen our analysis, to show how the mechanisms that underpin cinematic rhetorical patterns are the same as those providing coherence in written text. We draw on computational and psycholinguistic analyses of texts which have derived a set of relationships that are termed Cognitive Coherence Relations (CCR). We validate this by re-expressing established cinematic patterns, and relations relevant to scholarly hypertext, in terms of CCR, and with this conceptual bridge in place, present examples to show how cinematic techniques could assist the presentation of scholarly discourse. This theoretical work also informs system design. We describe how an abstract relational layer based on CCR is being implemented as a semantic hypertext system to mediate scholarly discourse.

REFERENCES

• 1: Mark Bernstein, Patterns of hypertext, Proceedings of the ninth ACM conference on Hypertext and hypermedia : links, objects, time and space---structure in hypermedia systems: links, objects, time and space---structure in hypermedia systems, p.21-29, June 20-24, 1998, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States [doi>10.1145/276627.276630]
• 2: Simon Buckingham Shum , John Domingue , Enrico Motta, Scholarly Discourse as Computable Structure, Proceedings of the 6th International Workshop and 2nd International Workshop on Open Hypertext Systems and Structural Computing, p.120-128, May 30-June 03, 2000
• 3: Buckingham Shum,S.,Motta,E.and Domingue,J. ScholOnto:An Ontology-Based Digital Library Server for Research Documents and Discourse. Int.Jnl.on Digital Libraries ,3,3,2000,pp.237-248 {www.kmi.open.ac.uk/projects/scholonto }.
• 4: Locke M. Carter, Arguments in hypertext: a rhetorical approach, Proceedings of the eleventh ACM on Hypertext and hypermedia, p.85-91, May 30-June 03, 2000, San Antonio, Texas, United States [doi>10.1145/336296.336332]
• 5: De Saussure,F.Cours de linguistique generale . Editions Payot:Paris,1922
• 6: Eastgate Systems:Storyspace {www.eastgate.com }
• 7: Gaudreault,A.Du Litteraire au Filmique.Systeme du Recit .Meridiens Klincksieck:Paris,1989
• 8: Genette,G.Figure III .Editions du Seuil:Paris, 1972
• 9: Knott,A.Similarity and Contrast Relations and Inductive Rules.In Proc.Workshop on Discourse Relations and Discourse Markers ,International Conference on Computational Linguistics,Montreal, CA,15th August,1998
• 10: Knott,A.Semantic and Pragmatic Relations and their Intended Effects.In:Text Representation: Linguistic and Psycholinguistic Aspects,Sanders,T., Schilperoorol,J.and Spooren,W.,(Ed.),Benjamins, 1999
• 11: Knott,A.and Dale,R.Using Linguistic Phenomena to Motivate a Set of Rhetorical Relations.University of Edinburgh,Technical Report HCRC/RP-39,1993
• 12: Knott,A.and Mellish,C.A Feature-Based Account of Relations Signalled by Sentence and Clause Connectives.Language and Speech ,39,2-3,1996, pp.143-183
• 13: Knott,A.and Sanders,T.The Classification of Coherence Relations and their Linguistic Markers: An Exploration of Two Languages.Journal of Pragmatics ,30,1998,pp.135-175
• 14: Kolb,D.Socrates in the Labyrinth:Hypertext, Argument,Philosophy (A Hypertext).Eastgate Systems:Watertown,1994 {www.eastgate.com }
• 15: David Kolb, Scholarly hypertext: self-represented complexity, Proceedings of the eighth ACM conference on Hypertext, p.29-37, April 06-11, 1997, Southampton, United Kingdom [doi>10.1145/267437.267441]
• 16: Kolb,D.:Assembly 3/1 version of the Sprawling Places hypertext project,(in press)
• 17: Marjorie C. Luesebrink, The moment in hypertext: a brief lexicon of time, Proceedings of the ninth ACM conference on Hypertext and hypermedia : links, objects, time and space---structure in hypermedia systems: links, objects, time and space---structure in hypermedia systems, p.106-112, June 20-24, 1998, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States [doi>10.1145/276627.276639]
• 18: Clara Mancini, From cinematographic to hypertext narrative, Proceedings of the eleventh ACM on Hypertext and hypermedia, p.236-237, May 30-June 03, 2000, San Antonio, Texas, United States [doi>10.1145/336296.336396]
• 19: Mann,W.C.and Thompson,S.A.Rhetorical Structure Theory:Toward a functional theory of text organisation.Text ,8,1988,pp.243-281
• 20: Metz,C.Essai sur la Signification au Cin~ma . Editions Klincksieck:Paris,1968
• 21: Metz,C.Le Significant Imaginaire.Psychanalyse et Cin~ma .Union G~n~rale d'Editions:Paris,1977
• 22: Miles,A.Cinematic Paradigms of Hipertext. Continuum:Journal of Media &Cultural Studies , 13.2,1999,pp.217-226
• 23: Adrian Miles, Hypertext structure as the event of connection, Proceedings of the twelfth ACM conference on Hypertext and Hypermedia, August 14-18, 2001, Århus, none, Denmark [doi>10.1145/504216.504236]
• 24: Peirce,C.Collected Papers .The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press:Cambridge,MA,1931- 1935
• 25: Lloyd Rutledge , Brian Bailey , Jacco van Ossenbruggen , Lynda Hardman , Joost Geurts, Generating presentation constraints from rhetorical structure, Proceedings of the eleventh ACM on Hypertext and hypermedia, p.19-28, May 30-June 03, 2000, San Antonio, Texas, United States [doi>10.1145/336296.336308]
• 26: Sanders,T.J.M.,Spooren,W.P.M.and Noordman, L.G.M.Coherence Relations in a Cognitive Theory of Discourse Representation.Cognitive Linguistics , 4,1993,pp.93-133
• 27: Nitin Sawhney , David Balcom , Ian Smith, HyperCafe: narrative and aesthetic properties of hypervideo, Proceedings of the the seventh ACM conference on Hypertext, p.1-10, March 16-20, 1996, Bethesda, Maryland, United States [doi>10.1145/234828.234829]
• 28: Frank M. Shipman, III , Haowei Hsieh , Preetam Maloor , J. Michael Moore, The visual knowledge builder: a second generation spatial hypertext, Proceedings of the twelfth ACM conference on Hypertext and Hypermedia, August 14-18, 2001, Århus, none, Denmark [doi>10.1145/504216.504245]
• 29: Frank M. Shipman, III , Catherine C. Marshall, Formality Considered Harmful: Experiences, EmergingThemes, and Directions on the Use of Formal Representations inInteractive Systems, Computer Supported Cooperative Work, v.8 n.4, p.333-352, Oct. 1999 [doi>10.1023/A:1008716330212]
• 30: Walton,D.G.Argumentation Schemes for Presumptive Reasoning .Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah: NJ, 1996

INDEX TERMS

Primary Classification:
  H. Information Systems
  H.5 INFORMATION INTERFACES AND PRESENTATION (I.7)
      H.5.4 Hypertext/Hypermedia
          Subjects: Theory

General Terms:
Design, Theory

Keywords:
argumentation, cinematic rhetoric, cognitive coherence relations, logical and analogical relations, scholarly hypertext, semiotics