Human-Computer Interaction in the Control of Dynamic Systems

ABSTRACT

Modes of human-computer interaction in the control of dynamic systems are discussed, and the problem of allocating tasks between human and computer considered. Models of human performance in a variety of tasks associated with the control of dynamic systems are reviewed. These models are evaluated in the context of a design example involving human-computer interaction in aircraft operations. Other examples include power plants, chemical plants, and ships.

REFERENCES

• BARO70: BARON, S., KLEINMAN, D. L., AND LEVI- SON, W.H. "An optimal control model of human response. Part II: Prediction of human performance in a complex task," Automatica 6, 3 (May 1970), 371-383.
• BARO77: BARON, S., AND LEVISON, W.H. "Display analysis using the optimal control model of the human operator," Hum. Factors 19, 4 (Oct. 1977), 437-457.
• BARO80a: BARON, S., MURALIDHARAN, R., LAN- CRAFT, R., AND ZACHARIAS, G. "PRO- CRU: A model for analyzing crew procedures in approach to landing," Bolt Beranek and Newman Rep. 4374, April 1980.
• BARO80b: BARON, S., AND LEVISON, W. H. "The optimal control model: Status and future directions," in Proc. IEEE Conf. Cybernetics and Society, Boston, 1980, pp. 90-100.
• BEKE77: BEKEY, G. A., BURNHAM, G. O., AND SEO, J. "Control theoretic models of human drivers in car following," Hum. Factors 19, 4 (Aug. 1977), 399-413.
• BIRM54: BIRMINGHAM, H. P., AND TAYLOR, F. "A design philosophy for man-machine control systems," Proc. IRE 42 (1954), 1748-1758.
• CARB66: CARBONELL, J.R. "A queueing model of many-instrument visual sampling," IEEE Trans. Hum. Factors in Electron. HFEo4, 4 (1966), 157-164.
• CARB68: CARBONELL, J. R., WARD, J. L., AND SENDERS, J. W. "A queueing model of visual sampling: Experimental validation," IEEE Trans. Man-Mach. Sys. MMS.9, 3 (1968), 82-87.
• CARB69: CARBONELL, J.R. "On man-computer interaction: A model and some related issues," IEEE Trans. Syst. Sci. Cybern. SSC-5, 1 (1989), 16-26.
• CHU79: CHU, Y. Y., AND ROUSE, W.B. "Adaptive allocation of decision making responsibility between human and computer in multitask situations," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-9, 12 (Dec. 1979), 769-778.
• CHUB80: CHUBS, G.P. "SAINT, a simulation language for the study of manned systems," in Proc. NATO Conf. Manned Systems Design, Freiburg, West Germany, 1980.
• CURR77: CURRY, R. E., KLEINMAN, D. L., AND HOFFMAN, W.C. "A design procedure for control/display systems," Hum. Factors 19, 4 (Oct. 1977), 421-436.
• CURR81: CURRY, R.E. "A model of fault detection for complex dynamic processes," in Human detection and diagnosis of system failures, J. Rasmussen and W. B. Rouse, Eds., Plenum Press, New York, 1981.
• DONG78: DONGES, E. "A two-level model of driver steering behavior," Hum. Factors 20, 6 (Dec. 1978), 691-707.
• DUNC74: DUNCAN, K.D. "Analytical techniques in training design," in The human operator in process control, E. Edwards and F. P. Lees, Eds., Taylor and Francis, London, 1974.
• ENST77: ENSTROM, K. D., AND ROUSE, W. B. "Real-time determination of how a human has allocated his attention between control and monitoring tasks," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-7, 3 (March 1977), 153-161.
• EPHR77: EFHRATH, A. R., AND CURRY, R. E. "Detection by pilots of systems failures during instrument landings," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-7, 12 (Dec. 1977), 841-848.
• FREU67: PREUND, L. E., AND SADOSKY, T. L. "Linear programming applied to optimization of instrument panel and workplace layout," Hum. Factors 9, 4 (Aug. 1967), 295-300.
• GAI76a: GAI, E. G., AND CURRY, R.E. "A model of the human observer in failure detection tasks," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-6, 2 (Feb. 1976), 85-94.
• GAI76b: GAI, E. G., AND CURRY, R. E. "Failure detection by pilots during automatic landings: Model and experiment," J. Aircr. 14, 2 (1976), 135-141.
• GOUL68: GOULD, J.D. "Visual factors in the design of computer-controlled crt displays," Hum. Factors 10, 4 (Aug. 1980), 359-376.
• GOVI79: GOVINDARAJ, T. "Modeling the human controller in a multi-task environment," Ph.D. dissertation, Univ. Illinois, Urbana, Coordinated Science Lab. Rep. T-87, Oct. 1979.
• GREE79: GREENSTEIN, J. S. "Human decision making in multi-task situations: Event detection, attention allocation, and implications for computer aiding," Ph.D. dissertation, Univ. Illinois, Urbana, Coordinated Science Lab. Rep. T-88, Oct. 1979.
• HAYE79: HAYES-ROTH, B., AND HAYES-ROTH, F. "A cognitive model of planning," Cognitive Sci. 3, 4 (Oct.-Dec. 1979), 275-310.
• IEEE79: "Special issue on Three Mile Island and the future of nuclear power," IEEE Spectrum 16, 11 (Nov. 1979).
• ISRA80: ISRAEL, d. B., WICKENS, C. D., CHESNEY, G. L., AND DONCHIN, E. "The event-related brain potential as an index of displaymonitoring workload," Hum. Factors 22, 2 (April 1980), 211-224.
• JOHA77: JOHANNSEN, G., BOLLER, H. E., DONGES, E., AND STEIN, W. Der mensch in regel. kreis: Lineare modelle, Oldenbourg, Munich, 1977.
• JOHA79: JOHANNSEN, G., AND ROUSE, W. B. "Mathematical concepts for modeling human behavior in complex man-machine systems," Hum. Factors 21, 6 (Dec. 1979), 733-747.
• JOHA80a: JOHANNSEN, G., AND GOVINDARAJ, T. "Optimal control model predictions of system performance and attention allocation and their experimental validation in a display design study," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-10, 5 (May 1980), 249- 261.
• JOHA80b: JOHANNSEN, G., AND ROUSE, W.B. "A study of the planning process of aircraft pilots in emergency and abnormal situations," in Proc. IEEE Conf. Cybernetics and Society, Boston, 1980, pp. 738-745.
• KAHN73: KAHNEMAN, D. Attention and effort, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1973.
• KATZ75: KATZ, E.H. "Sizing of dynamic display parameters," Proc. SID 16, 4 (1975), 223- 226.
• KELL68: KELLEY, C. R. Manual and automatic control, Academic Press, New York, 1968.
• KLEI70: KLEINMAN, D. L., BARON, S., AND LEVI- SON, W.H. "An optimal control model of human response. Part I: Theory and validation," Automatica 6, 3 (May 1970), 357- 369.
• KLEI74: KLEINMAN, D. L., AND PERKINS, T. "Modeling the human in a time-varying anti-aircraft tracking loop," IEEE Trans. Autom. Control AC-19, 4 (Aug. 1974), 297-306.
• KLEI76: KLEINMAN, D. L. "Solving the optimal attention allocation problem in manual control," IEEE Trans. Autom. Control AC-21, 6 (Dec. 1976).
• KLEI77: KLEINMAN, D. L., AND CURRY, R. E. "Some new control theoretic models for human operator display monitoring," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-7, 11 (Nov. 1977), 778-784.
• KOK78: KoK, J. J., AND VAN WIJK, R. A. "Evaluation of models describing human operator control of slowly responding complex systems," Ph.D. dissertation, Delft Univ. Technology, Delft, The Netherlands, 1978.
• KRAG78: KRAGT, H., AND LANDEWEERD, J. A. "Mental skills in process control," in The human operator in process control, E. Edwards and F. P. Lees, Eds., Taylor and Francis, London, 1974.
• KRAI80: KRAISS, K. F. "Analytical evaluation of manned systems with network models," in Proc. NATO Conf. Manned Systems, Freiburg, West Germany, 1980.
• LAIN76: LAINIOTIS, D. G., Ed. "Special issue on adaptive systems," Proc. IEEE 64, 8 (Aug. 1979).
• LEVI71: LEVISON, W. H., ELKIND, J. I., AND WARD, J .L . "Studies of multivariable manual control systems: A model for task interference," NASA CR-1746, May 1971.
• LICK60: LICKLIDER, J. C. R. "Man-computer symbiosis," IEEE Trans. Hum. Factors in Electron. HFE-1, 1 (1960), 4-11.
• MCRU74: McRUER, D. T., AND KRENDEL, E. S. "Mathematical models of human pilot behavior," Advisory Group on Aerospace Research and Development AGARDograph 180, Jan. 1974.
• MCRU77: MCRUER, D. T., ALLEN, R. W., WEIR, D. H., AND KLEIN, R. H. "New results in driver steering control models," Hum. Factors 19, 4 (Aug. 1977), 381-397.
• MILL67: MILLER, D. C., AND ELKIND, J. I. "The adaptive response of the human controller to sudden changes in controlled process dynamics," IEEE Trans. Hum. Factors in Electron. HFE-8, 3 (Sept. 1967), 218-223.
• MONA79: MONAN, W. P. "Distraction--A human factor in air carrier hazard events," in NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System: Ninth Quarterly Report, Tecb. Memo. 78608, NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, Calif., June 1979.
• MORA79: MORAY, N., Ed. Mental workload, Plenum Press, New York, 1979.
• MURA79: MURALIDHARAN, R., AND BARON, S. "DEMON: A human operator model for decision making, monitoring, and control," in Proc. 15th Annual Conf. Manual Control, Wright State Univ., Dayton, Ohio, 1979.
• NAVO79: NAVON, D., AND GOPHER, D. "On the economy of the human-processing system," Psychol. Rev. 86, 3 (May 1979), 214- 255.
• NEIS76: NEISSER, U. Cognition and reality, Freeman, San Francisco, 1976.
• NEWE72: Allen Newell, Human Problem Solving, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Upper Saddle River, NJ, 1972
• NIEM75: NIEMELA, R. J., AND KRENDEL," E. S. "Detection of a change in plant dynamics in a man-machine system," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-5, 11 (Nov. 1975), 615-617.
• NORM75: NORMAN, D. A., AND BOBROW, D.G. "On data-limited and resource-limited proceases," Cognitive Psychol. 7, 1 (1975), 44- 64.
• PALM77: PALMER, E. "Interrupted monitoring of a stochastic process," in Proc. 13th Annual Conf. Manual Control, M.I.T., Cambridge, Mass., 1977, pp. 237-244.
• PARK79: PARKS, D.L. "Current workload methods and emerging challenges," in Mental workload, N. Moray, Ed., Plenum Press, New York, 1979.
• PATT79: PATTIPATI, K. R., EPHRATH, A. R., AND KLEINMAN, D.L. "Analysis of human decision making in multi-task environments," Univ. Connecticut Rep. EECS TR-79-15, Nov. 1979.
• PHAT69: PHATAK, A. V., AND BEEEY, G. A. "Decision processes in the adaptive behavior of human controllers," IEEE Trans. Syst. Sci. Cybern. SSC-5, 4 (1969), 333- 351.
• PHAT77: PHATAK, A. V., AND KESSLER, K. M. "Modeling the human gunner in an anti-aircraft artillery (AAA) tracking task," Hum. Factors 19, 5 (Oct. 1977), 477-494.
• RABI76: RABINER, L. R., Ed. "Special issue on man-machine communication by voice," Proc. IEEE 64, 4 (April 1976).
• RAMS79: RAMSEY, H. R., AND ATWOOD, M. E. "Human factors in computer systems: A review of the literature," Rep. SAI-79- 111-DEN (AD AO75679), Science Applications Inc., Englewood, Col., Sept. 1979.
• RASM74: RASMUSSEN, J., AND JENSEN, A. "Mental procedures in real-life tasks: A case study of electronic troubleshooting," Ergonomics 17, 3 (1974), 293-307.
• RASM78: RASMUSSEN, J. "Notes on diagnostic strategies in process plant environments," Rep. Riso-M-1983, Riso National Lab., Roskilde, Denmark, 1978.
• RASM79: RASMUSSEN, J. "The human as a system component," in Man computer research, H. Smith and T. Green, Eds., Academic Press, New York, 1979.
• RASM81: RASMUSSEN, J., AND ROUSE, W. B., Eds. Human detection and diagnosis of system failures, Plenum Press, New York, 1981.
• REGA79: REGAN, D. "Electrical responses evoked from the human brain," Sci. Am. 241, 6 (Dec. 1979), 108-117.
• RIJN77: RIJNSDORP, J. E., AND ROUSE, W. B. "Design of man-machine interfaces in process control," in Digital computer applications to process control, H. R. Van Nauta Lemke and H. B. Verbruggen, Eds., North-Holland, New York, 1977.
• ROUS75a: RousE, W.B. "Human interaction with an intelligent computer in multi-task situations," in Proc. 11th Annual Conf. Manual Control, NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, Calif., 1975, pp. 130-143.
• ROUS75b: RousE, W.B. "Design of man-computer interfaces for on-line interactive systems," Proc. IEEE 63, 6 (June 1975), 847-857.
• ROUS76: RousE, W.B. "Adaptive allocation of decision making responsibility between supervisor and computer," in Monitoring behavior and supervisory control, T. B. Sheridan and G. Johannsen, Eds., Plenum Press, New York, 1976.
• ROUS77: RousE, W.B. "Human-computer interaction in multi-task situations," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-7, 5 (May 1977), 384-392.
• ROUS78: ROUSE, W.B. "A model of human decision making in a fault diagnosis task," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-8, 5 (May 1978), 357-361.
• ROUS79a: ROUSE, W.B. "A model of human decision making in fault diagnosis tasks that include feedback and redundancy," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-9, 4 (April 1979), 237-241.
• ROUS79b: ROUSE, W. B., AND ROUSE, S. H. "Measures of complexity of fault diagnosis tasks," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-9, 11 (Nov. 1979), 720-727.
• ROUS80a: ROUSE, W. B., ROUSE, S. H., AND PELLE- ORXNO, S.J. "A rule-based model of human problem solving in fault diagnosis tasks," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-10, 7 (July 1980), 366-376.
• ROUS80b: RousE, W. B. Systems engineering models of human-machine interaction, North-Holland, New York, 1980.
• ROUS80c: RousE, S. H., AND ROUSE, W. B. "Computer-based manuals for procedural information," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-10, 8 (Aug. 1980), 506- 510.
• ROUS80d: ROUSE, S. H., ROUSE, W. B., AND HAM- MER, J.M. "Design and an approach to evaluation of an onboard computer-based information system for aircraft," in Proc. IEEE Conf. Cybernetics and Society, Boston, 1980, pp. 396-403.
• ROUS80e: ROUSE, W. B., AND HUNT, R.M. "A fuzzy rule-based model of human problem solving performance in fault diagnosis tasks," Working Paper, Univ. Illinois at Urbana- Champaign, Sept. 1980.
• ROUS81: ROUSE, W.B. "Experimental studies and mathematical models of human problem solving in fault diagnosis tasks," in Human detection and diagnosis of system failures, J. Rasmussen and W. B. Rouse, Eds., Plenum Press, New York, 1981.
• RUFF79: RUFFEL SMITH, H.P. "A simulator study of the interaction of pilot workload with errors, vigilance, and decisions," Tech. Memo. 78482, NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, Calif., 1979.
• SCHA77: SCHANK, R. C., AND ABELSON, R. P. Scripts, plans, goals, and understanding, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J., 1977.
• SEND64: SENDERS, J.W. "The human observer as a monitor and controller of multidegree of freedom systems," IEEE Trans. Hum. Factors in Electron. HFE-5, 1 (Sept. 1964).
• SEND76: SENDERS, J. W., AND POSNER, M. J. "A queueing model of monitoring and supervisory behavior," in Monitoring behavior and supervisory control, T. B Sheridan and G. Johannsen, Eds., Plenum Press, New York, 1976.
• SHER74: SHERIDAN, T. B., AND FERRELL, W. R. Man-machine systems: Information, control, and decision models of human performance, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1974.
• SHER76: Thomas B. Sheridan , G. Johannsen, Monitoring Behavior and Supervisory Control, Perseus Publishing, 1976
• SHER79: SHERR, S. Electronic displays, Wiley, New York, 1979.
• SMAL67: SMALLWOOD, R.D. "Internal models and the human instrument monitor," IEEE Trans. Hum. Factors in Electron. HFE-8, 3 (Sept. 1967), 181-187.
• TULG78: TULGA, M.K. "Dynamic decision making in multi-task supervisory control: Comparison of an optimal algorithm to human behavior," Sc.D. dissertation, M.I.T., Cambridge, Mass., 1978.
• VEIT79: VEITGRUBER, J. E. "Warning systems," in Proc. Symp. Human Factors in Civil Aviation, The Hague, 1979.
• VELD77: VELDHUYZEN, W., AND STASSEN, H. G. "The internal model concept: An application to modeling human control of large ships," Hum. Factors 19, 4 (Aug. 1977), 367-380.
• WALD78: WALDEN, R. S., AND ROUSE, W. B. "A queueing model of pilot decision making in a multi-task flight management task," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-8, 12 (Dec. 1978), 867-875.
• WESS77: WESSON, R.B. "Planning in the world of the air traffic controller," in Proc. 5th Inter. Joint Conf. Artificial Intelligence, M.I.T., Cambridge, Mass., 1977, pp. 473-479.
• WHER76: WHERRY, R. J. "The human operator simulator--HOS," in Monitoring behavior and supervisory control, T. B. Sheridan and G. Johannsen, Eds., Plenum Press, New York, 1976.
• WICK79a: WICKENS, C. D., AND KESSEL, C. "The effects of participatory mode and task workload on the detection of dynamic system failures," IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern. SMC-9, 1 (Jan. 1979), 24-34.
• WICK79b: WICKENS, C.D. "The structure of attentional resources," in Attention and performance VIII, R. Nickerson and R. Pew, Eds., Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J., 1979.
• WINS77: Patrick Henry Winston, Artificial intelligence (2nd ed.), Addison-Wesley Longman Publishing Co., Inc., Boston, MA, 1984
• YOUN69: YOUNG, L.R. "On adaptive manual control," IEEE Trans. Man-Mach. Syst. MMS-10, 4 (1969), 292-331.

INDEX TERMS

Primary Classification:
  H. Information Systems
  H.1 MODELS AND PRINCIPLES
      H.1.2 User/Machine Systems

Additional Classification:
  J. Computer Applications
  J.2 PHYSICAL SCIENCES AND ENGINEERING
      Subjects: Engineering
  J.7 COMPUTERS IN OTHER SYSTEMS
      Subjects: Process control

General Terms:
Human Factors

Keywords:
aircraft, control, dynamic systems, human-computer interaction, mathematical models, system design, task analysis