What makes professionals so difficult: an investigation into professional ethics teaching

ABSTRACT

Teaching ethics to professionals pursuing a university degree programme requires a method that engages them with the realities and problematic nature of their workplace environment. In this paper we examine some of the history of Professional Ethics from a philosophical and political standpoint. Unfortunately this analysis appears to produce more questions than answers with the terms professional and expert seemingly poorly defined. In order to demonstrate some of the generic problems likely to be encountered by anyone teaching Professional Ethics we make use of our case study. Whilst this is concerned largely with what can be termed Business and Computing Ethics, the case study does highlight problems that occur across the curricula. We look at the concerns and problems surrounding the teaching of issues such as Integration into the Curricula, Codes of Ethics, Ethical Decision Making and Ethical Standards. We stress the value in universities moving away from traditional methods, based purely in direct value, of decision making to an alternative ethical evaluative framework based on Social, Economic, Environmental and Rights information. This model should be introduced early in the student calendar and used as a vehicle for discussion of later issues such as Whistleblowing.

REFERENCES

• 1: ACM The Durango Declaration (1995) Communications of the ACM Vol. 38 No. 10 pp. 1
• 2: ALAM, K.F (1995) Attitudes Towards Business Ethics of Business Students in Malaysia Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 14 pp. 309-313
• 3: ANNAS, G & HADDAD, A (1994) Do Ethics Committees Work? Hospitals & Health Networks May pp 6
• 4: ARLOW, P (1991) Personal Characteristics in College Students' Evaluations of Business Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 10 pp. 63-69
• 5: BLUESTONE, B & HARRISON, B (1990) The Great U-Turn Basic Books: New York
• 6: BOK, D (1988) Can Higher Education Foster Higher Morals? Business & Society Review Vol. 66 pp. 4-12
• 7: BOMMER, M., GRATTO, C., GRAVANDER, J & TUTTLE, M (1987) A Behavioural Model of Unethical Decision Making Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 6 pp. 265-280
• 8: BROOKS, B.D. & McCARTHY, P.J (1989) Teaching the Two Rs: Right and 'Rong': Business & Society Review Vol. 68 pp. 52-55
• 9: BUNKE, H.C (1988) Should We Teach Business Ethics? Business Horizons Vol. 31 pp. 2-8
• 10: BURTON, S., JOHNSON, M.W., & WILSON, E.J (1991) An Experimental Assessment of Mternative Teaching Approaches for Introducing Business Ethics to Undergraduate Business Students Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 10 pp. 507-517
• 11: CALLAHAN, E.S & DWORKIN (1994) T.M Who blows the whistle to the media, and why: Organisational characteristics of media whistleblowers American Business Law JournaIVol. 32(2) pp 151-4
• 12: CLARKE, R (1988) Economic, Legal and Social Implications of Information Technology Dec. MIS Quarterly pp. 517-519
• 13: COUGAR, J.D (1989) Preparing IS students to Deal with Ethical Issues MIS Quarterly pp 210-218 June
• 14: COWTON, C.J & DUNFEE, T.W (1995) Internationalizing the Business Ethics Curriculum: A Survey Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 14 pp. 331-338
• 15: DAVIS, J.R & WELTON, R.E (1991) Professional Ethics: Business Students' Perceptions Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 10 pp. 451-463
• 16: DUNFEE, T.W & ROBERTSON, D.C (1988) Integrating Ethics into the Business Curriculum Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 7 pp. 847-859
• 17: ETZIONI, A (1989) Are Business Schools Brainwashing their MBAs?: Business & Society Review Vol. 70 pp. 18-19
• 18: FERRIS, W.P (1992) Business Ethics and the Use of Personal E#hics Codes: Proc. National Academy of Management Meeting, Las Vegas, Nevada
• 19: FITZGERALD, M (1994) Michigan j-school sued under whistleblower law Editor and Publisher Sept. page 20
• 20: FURMAN, F.K (1990) Teaching Business Ethics: Questioning the Assumptions, Seeking New Directions Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 9 pp. 31-38
• 21: GANDZE, J. & HAYES, N (1988) Teaching Business Ethics Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 7 pp. 657-669
• 22: GLENN, J.R (1992) Can a Business and Society Course Affect the Ethical Judgement of Future Manager? Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 11 pp. 217-223
• 23: GOODPASTER, K (1985) Toward an Integrated Approach to Business Ethics Thought Vol. 60 pp. 161-180
• 24: HALFOND, J (1990) Should Business Schools Be Sunday Schools?: Business & Society Review Vol. 72 pp. 54-55
• 25: HARRIS E.H & RABINS J.R (1993) Two Methods for Ethics Case Analysis Proc. IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference pp. 411-424 IEEE Press New York USA
• 26: HOSMER, La Rue T (1985) The Other 338: Why a Majority of Our Schools of Business Administration Do Not Offer a Course in Business Ethics Journal of Business Ethics VoI. 4 pp. 17-22
• 27: HOSMER, La Rue T (1988) Adding Ethics to the Business Curriculum Business Horizons Vol. 31 pp. 9-15
• 28: HUME, D (1988) A Treatise of Human Nature Vol. 3 (ed.) Selby-Bigge, L.A Clarendon Press: London JONATHAN, R (1983) The manpower service model of education Cambridge Journal of Education Voi. 13 No. 2 pp. 3-10
• 29: JONES, T.M (1989) Can Business Ethics Be Taught? Business & Professional Ethics Journal Vol. 8 pp. 73-88
• 30: KEEP, E (1993) Missing presumed skilled IN Adult Learners, Education and Training (eds.) Edwards, R, Sieminski, S & Zeldin, D Routledge: London
• 31: KELSEY, J (1995) Economic Fundamentalism Pluto Press: London
• 32: KENNEDY, E.J & LAWTON, L (1992) Business Ethics in Fiction Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 1I pp. 187-195
• 33: KERTESZ, L (1995) Modern Healthcare pp 11
• 34: KHAZANCHI, D (1995) Unethical Behaviour in Information Systems: The Gender Factor Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 14 pp. 741-749
• 35: KIERKEGAARD, S (197I) Either/Or Vols. 1 & 2 Princeton Univ. Press : USA
• 36: Joseph Migga Kizza, Social and Ethical Effects of the Computer Revolution, McFarland & Company, Inc. Publishers, 1996
• 37: LABOUR PARTY (1995) University far Industry Consultative document LPP: London
• 38: Karen D. Loch , Sue Conger, Evaluating ethical decision making and computer use, Communications of the ACM, v.39 n.7, p.74-83, July 1996 [doi>10.1145/233977.233999]
• 39: van LUIJK, H.J.L (1990) Recent Development in European Business Ethics Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 9 pp. 537-544
• 40: MACINTYRE, A (1985) After Virtue." a study in moral theory Duckworth: London
• 41: MAHONEY, J (1990) Teaching Business Ethics in the UK, Europe and USA: A Comparative Study Athlone Press: London
• 42: MERRITT, S (1991) Marketing Ethics and Education: Some Empirical Findings Journal Of Business Ethics Vol. 10 pp. 625-632
• 43: NELSON, D.R & OBREMSK1, T.E (1990) Promoting Moral Growth Through Intra-group Participation Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 9 pp. 731-739
• 44: di NORCIA, V (1994) Ethics, Technology Development and Innovation Business Ethics Quarterly Vol. 4 Iss: 3 pp. 235-252
• 45: PARMENTAL, G.L (I989) The Course in Business Ethics: Can it Work? Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 8 pp. 47-51
• 46: PARSONS, T (I957) The Distribution of Power in American Society World Politics: London
• 47: PARSONS, T & SMELSER, N.J (1956) Economy & Society Free Press: Illinois USA
• 48: PASCALE, R.T & ATHOS, A.G (198 I) The Art of Japanese Management Simon & Schuster
• 49: PETERS, p.J & WATERMAN, R.H (1982) In Search of Excellence: Lessons from America's Best Run Companies Harper & Row
• 50: POORSCOLTAN, K., AMIN, S.G & TOOTOONCHI, A (1991) Business Ethics: Views of Future Leaders SAM AdvancementJournal Vol. 56(1) pp. 4-9
• 51: PROJECT IMPACTCS STEERING COMMITTEE (1995) The Consequences of Computing: A #amework for Teaching the Social and Ethical Impact of Computing ACM Full Report 65 pages: New York USA
• 52: RODITTI, E.C (I995) Using Nondisclosure Agreements to Prevent Leaks Employment Relations Today pp. 39-46
• 53: SCHON, D (1983) The Reflective Practitioner Basic: New York
• 54: SCHOENFELDT, L,F., McDONALD, D.M & YOUNGBLOOD, S.A (1991) The Teaching of Business Ethics: A Survey of AACSB Member Schools Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 10 pp. 237-241
• 55: SIMS, R.R & SIMS, S.J (1991) Increasing Applied Business Ethics Courses in Business Schools Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 10 pp. 211-219
• 56: SOLBERG, S, STRONG, K & McGUIRE, C (I995) Living (Not Learning) Ethics Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 14 pp. 71-81
• 57: SOLOMON, S & O'BR1EN J.A (1990) The Effects of Demographic Factors on Attitudes Towards Software Piracy Journal of Computer Information Systems Vol. 30(3) pp. 168-181
• 58: SMITH, A (1987) Correspondence of Adam Smith Liberty Press: Indiana USA
• 59: SMITH, A (1993) An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations Oxford University Press : Oxford
• 60: SMITH, A (1982) The Theory of Moral Sentiments Liberty Press: Indiana USA
• 61: STERN, A (1995) A Study in Diplomacy Across the Board pp 20-24 .
• 62: STRONG, V.K & HOFFMAN, A.N (1990) There is Relevance in the Classroom: Analysis of Present Methods of Teaching Business Ethics Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 9 pp. 603-607
• 63: TEEPLE, G (1995) Globalization and the Decline of Social Reform Humanities Press: New Jersey USA
• 64: TOZER, E (1993) Direct Versus Indirect: Is their a choice? Management Today Seminar Series
• 65: VEBLEN (1918) The Higher Learning in America: a Memorandum on the Conduct of Universities by Business Men Huebsch New York USA
• 66: VICTOR, B & CULLEN, J.B (1988) The organizational bases of ethical work climates Administrative Science Q. Vol.: 33(3) pp: 101-125
• 67: VYGOTSKII, L.S (1978) Mind in Society, the development of higher psychological processes Harvard University Press: USA
• 68: WEBER, J (1990) Measuring the Impact of Teaching Ethics to Future Managers: A Review Assessment and Recommendations Journal of Business Ethics Vol. 9 pp. 183-190
• 69: WEBER, M (1992) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism' Routledge London
• 70: ZURER, P (1995) Scientific misconduct hearing neglects universities' role Chemical and Engineering News Vol. 73 Iss: 35 page 33

INDEX TERMS

Primary Classification:
  K. Computing Milieux
  K.7 THE COMPUTING PROFESSION
      K.7.4 Professional Ethics
          Subjects: Codes of ethics

Additional Classification:
  H. Information Systems
  H.1 MODELS AND PRINCIPLES
      H.1.2 User/Machine Systems
          Subjects: Human factors

  K. Computing Milieux
  K.3 COMPUTERS AND EDUCATION
      K.3.2 Computer and Information Science Education
          Subjects: Curriculum
  K.4 COMPUTERS AND SOCIETY
      K.4.1 Public Policy Issues
          Subjects: Ethics

General Terms:
Human Factors, Theory