A comparison of software platforms for wireless sensor networks: MANTIS, TinyOS, and ZigBee

ABSTRACT

Wireless sensor networks are characterized by very tight code size and power constraints and by a lack of well-established standard software development platforms such as Posix. In this article, we present a comparative study between a few fairly different such platforms, namely MANTIS, TinyOS, and ZigBee, when considering them from the application developer's perspective, that is, by focusing mostly on functional aspects, rather than on performance or code size. In other words, we compare both the tasking model used by these platforms and the API libraries they offer. Sensor network applications are basically event based, so most of the software platforms are also built on considering event handling mechanism, however some use a more traditional thread based model. In this article, we consider implementations of a simple generic application in MANTIS, TinyOS, and the Ember ZigBee development framework, with the goal of depicting major differences between these platforms, and suggesting a programming style aimed at maximizing portability between them.

REFERENCES

• 1: T. Abdelzaher , B. Blum , Q. Cao , Y. Chen , D. Evans , J. George , S. George , L. Gu , T. He , S. Krishnamurthy , L. Luo , S. Son , J. Stankovic , R. Stoleru , A. Wood, EnviroTrack: Towards an Environmental Computing Paradigm for Distributed Sensor Networks, Proceedings of the 24th International Conference on Distributed Computing Systems (ICDCS'04), p.582-589, March 24-26, 2004
• 2: Amol Bakshi , Jingzhao Ou , Viktor K. Prasanna, Towards automatic synthesis of a class of application-specific sensor networks, Proceedings of the 2002 international conference on Compilers, architecture, and synthesis for embedded systems, October 08-11, 2002, Grenoble, France [doi>10.1145/581630.581639]
• 3: Amol Bakshi , Viktor K. Prasanna, Algorithm Design and Synthesis for Wireless Sensor Networks, Proceedings of the 2004 International Conference on Parallel Processing, p.423-430, August 15-18, 2004 [doi>10.1109/ICPP.2004.14]
• 4: Amol Bakshi , Viktor K. Prasanna , Jim Reich , Daniel Larner, The Abstract Task Graph: a methodology for architecture-independent programming of networked sensor systems, Proceedings of the 2005 workshop on End-to-end, sense-and-respond systems, applications and services, June 05-05, 2005, Seattle, Washington
• 5: Barry, R. 2003. FreeRTOS, A FREE open source RTOS for small embedded real time systems. http://www.freertos.org/PC/.
• 6: BeeKit. 2004. Freescale's BeeKit. www.freescale.com/zigbee.
• 7: Shah Bhatti , James Carlson , Hui Dai , Jing Deng , Jeff Rose , Anmol Sheth , Brian Shucker , Charles Gruenwald , Adam Torgerson , Richard Han, MANTIS OS: an embedded multithreaded operating system for wireless micro sensor platforms, Mobile Networks and Applications, v.10 n.4, p.563-579, August 2005 [doi>10.1145/1160162.1160178]
• 8: BOS. 2006. Jennic: Basic Operating System (BOS) API. http://www.jennic.com/.
• 9: Adam Dunkels , Bjorn Gronvall , Thiemo Voigt, Contiki - A Lightweight and Flexible Operating System for Tiny Networked Sensors, Proceedings of the 29th Annual IEEE International Conference on Local Computer Networks, p.455-462, November 16-18, 2004 [doi>10.1109/LCN.2004.38]
• 10: Ember. 2001. Zigbee Wireless Semiconductor Solutions by Ember. www.ember.com.
• 11: Freescale. 2008. Freescale, 802.15.4 Media Access Controller MyWirelessApp User Guide. http://www.freescale.com.
• 12: Wai Fu Fung , David Sun , Johannes Gehrke, COUGAR: the network is the database, Proceedings of the 2002 ACM SIGMOD international conference on Management of data, June 03-06, 2002, Madison, Wisconsin [doi>10.1145/564691.564775]
• 13: Gummadi, R., Gnawali, O., and Govindan, R. 2005. Macro-programming wireless sensor networks using kairos. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Distributed Computing in Sensor Systems (DCOSS). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany.
• 14: Nicolas Halbwachs, Synchronous Programming of Reactive Systems, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Norwell, MA, 1992
• 15: IEEE. 2003. IEEE 802.15.4 WPAN-LR Task Group. http://www.ieee802.org/15/pub/TG4.html.
• 16: Jaikaeo, C., Srisathapornphat, C., and Shen, C.-C. 2000. Querying and tasking in sensor networks. In Proceedings of the 14th Annual International Symposium on Aerospace/Defense Sensing, Simulation, and Control. Elsevier Science Ltd., Oxford, UK.
• 17: Levis, P., Madden, S., Gay, D., Polastre, J., Szewczyk, R., Whitehouse, K., Woo, A., Gay, D., Hill, J., Welsh, M., Brewer, E., and Culler, D. 2004. TinyOS: An Operating System for Sensor Networks. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany.
• 18: Samuel R. Madden , Michael J. Franklin , Joseph M. Hellerstein , Wei Hong, TinyDB: an acquisitional query processing system for sensor networks, ACM Transactions on Database Systems (TODS), v.30 n.1, p.122-173, March 2005 [doi>10.1145/1061318.1061322]
• 19: Ryan Mannion , Harry Hsieh , Susan Cotterell , Frank Vahid, System Synthesis for Networks of Programmable Blocks, Proceedings of the conference on Design, Automation and Test in Europe, p.888-893, March 07-11, 2005 [doi>10.1109/DATE.2005.289]
• 20: Mozumdar, M. M. R., Gregoretti, F., Lavagno, L., Vanzago, L., and Olivieri, S. 2008. A framework for modeling, simulation and automatic code generation of sensor network application. In Proceedings of the 5th Annual IEEE Communications Society Conference on Sensor, Mesh and Ad Hoc Communications and Networks (SECON'08). IEEE, Los Alamitos, CA.
• 21: Ryan Newton , Matt Welsh, Region streams: functional macroprogramming for sensor networks, Proceeedings of the 1st international workshop on Data management for sensor networks: in conjunction with VLDB 2004, August 30-30, 2004, Toronto, Canada [doi>10.1145/1052199.1052213]
• 22: Rtw. 2008. Real-Time Workshop - Generate C code from Simulink models and MATLAB code. http://www.mathworks.com/products/rtw/.
• 23: SF. 2008. Stateflow - Design and simulate state machines and control logic. http://www.mathworks.com/products/stateflow/.
• 24: Texas. 1996. ZigBee: IEEE 802.15.4 from Texas Instruments.
• 25: ZigBee. 2002. ZigBee Alliance. http://www.zigbee.org/.

INDEX TERMS

Primary Classification:
  D. Software
  D.4 OPERATING SYSTEMS
      D.4.7 Organization and Design

General Terms:
Algorithms, Design, Languages

Keywords:
Wireless sensor networks, application porting, software platform