The anatomy of prototypes: Prototypes as filters, prototypes as manifestations of design ideas

ABSTRACT

The role of prototypes is well established in the field of HCI and Design. A lack of knowledge, however, about the fundamental nature of prototypes still exists. Researchers have attempted to identify different types of prototypes, such as low- vs. high-fidelity prototypes, but these attempts have centered on evaluation rather than support of design exploration. There have also been efforts to provide new ways of thinking about the activity of using prototypes, such as experience prototyping and paper prototyping, but these efforts do not provide a discourse for understanding fundamental characteristics of prototypes. In this article, we propose an anatomy of prototypes as a framework for prototype conceptualization. We view prototypes not only in their role in evaluation but also in their generative role in enabling designers to reflect on their design activities in exploring a design space. We base this framework on the findings of two case studies that reveal two key dimensions: prototypes as filters and prototypes as manifestations. We explain why these two dimensions are important and how this conceptual framework can benefit our field by establishing more solid and systematic knowledge about prototypes and prototyping.

REFERENCES

• 1: Adams, R. 2002. Understanding design iteration: Representations from an empirical study. In Proceedings of Common Ground International Conference, London, Design Research Society.
• 2: Anatomy. 2006. Oxford English Dictionary. Oxford University Press. http://www.oed.com/.
• 3: Alexander, C., Ishikawa, S., and Silverstein, M., with Jacobson, M., Fikidahl-King, I, and Angel, S. 1977. A Pattern Language, Oxford University Press, London, UK.
• 4: Daniel Avrahami , Scott E. Hudson, Forming interactivity: a tool for rapid prototyping of physical interactive products, Proceedings of the 4th conference on Designing interactive systems: processes, practices, methods, and techniques, June 25-28, 2002, London, England [doi>10.1145/778712.778735]
• 5: Brian P. Bailey , Joseph A. Konstan , John V. Carlis, DEMAIS: designing multimedia applications with interactive storyboards, Proceedings of the ninth ACM international conference on Multimedia, September 30-October 05, 2001, Ottawa, Canada [doi>10.1145/500141.500179]
• 6: Eva Brandt , Jörn Messeter, Facilitating collaboration through design games, Proceedings of the eighth conference on Participatory design: Artful integration: interweaving media, materials and practices, July 27-31, 2004, Toronto, Ontario, Canada [doi>10.1145/1011870.1011885]
• 7: Marion Buchenau , Jane Fulton Suri, Experience prototyping, Proceedings of the 3rd conference on Designing interactive systems: processes, practices, methods, and techniques, p.424-433, August 17-19, 2000, New York City, New York, United States [doi>10.1145/347642.347802]
• 8: Buxton, B. 2007. Sketching User Experiences: Getting the Design Right and the Right Design, Morgan Kaufmann, San Francisco, CA.
• 9: Andy Clark, Natural-Born Cyborgs?, Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Cognitive Technology: Instruments of Mind, p.17-24, August 06-09, 2001
• 10: Gilbert Cockton , Alan Woolrych, Sale must end: should discount methods be cleared off HCI's shelves?, interactions, v.9 n.5, September 2002 [doi>10.1145/566981.566990]
• 11: Gregorio Convertino , Dennis C. Neale , Laurian Hobby , John M. Carroll , Mary Beth Rosson, A laboratory method for studying activity awareness, Proceedings of the third Nordic conference on Human-computer interaction, p.313-322, October 23-27, 2004, Tampere, Finland [doi>10.1145/1028014.1028063]
• 12: R. Budde , K. Kuhlenkamp , L. Mathiassen , L. Zullighoven, Approaches to Prototyping, Springer-Verlag New York, Inc., Secaucus, NJ, 1984
• 13: Goel, V. and Pirolli, P. 1992. The structure of design problem spaces. Cognitive Science 16, 395--429.
• 14: Helen M. Grady, Web site design: a case study in usability testing using paper prototypes, Proceedings of IEEE professional communication society international professional communication conference and Proceedings of the 18th annual ACM international conference on Computer documentation: technology & teamwork, September 24-27, 2000, Cambridge, Massachusetts
• 15: Saul Greenberg , Michael Boyle, Customizable physical interfaces for interacting with conventional applications, Proceedings of the 15th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology, October 27-30, 2002, Paris, France [doi>10.1145/571985.571991]
• 16: O. Gutierrez, Prototyping techniques for different problem contexts, Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems: Wings for the mind, p.259-264, March 1989
• 17: William Jones , Jared Spool , Jonathan Grudin , Victoria Bellotti , Mary Czerwinski, "Get real!": what's wrong with hci prototyping and how can we fix it?, CHI '07 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems, April 28-May 03, 2007, San Jose, CA, USA [doi>10.1145/1240866.1240922]
• 18: James A. Landay, SILK: sketching interfaces like krazy, Conference companion on Human factors in computing systems: common ground, p.398-399, April 13-18, 1996, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada [doi>10.1145/257089.257396]
• 19: Johnny C. Lee , Daniel Avrahami , Scott E. Hudson , Jodi Forlizzi , Paul H. Dietz , Darren Leigh, The calder toolkit: wired and wireless components for rapidly prototyping interactive devices, Proceedings of the 5th conference on Designing interactive systems: processes, practices, methods, and techniques, August 01-04, 2004, Cambridge, MA, USA [doi>10.1145/1013115.1013139]
• 20: Levy, S. 2006. The Perfect Thing, Wired 14, 11 (http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.11/ipod.html.)
• 21: Horst Lichter , Matthias Schneider-Hufschmidt , Heinz Züllighoven, Prototyping in industrial software projects—bridging the gap between theory and practice, Proceedings of the 15th international conference on Software Engineering, p.221-229, May 17-21, 1993, Baltimore, Maryland, United States
• 22: Lim, Y. 2003. Design information framework for integrating multiple aspects of design, Ph.D. dissertation, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, IL.
• 23: Youn-kyung Lim , Apurva Pangam , Subashini Periyasami , Shweta Aneja, Comparative analysis of high- and low-fidelity prototypes for more valid usability evaluations of mobile devices, Proceedings of the 4th Nordic conference on Human-computer interaction: changing roles, p.291-300, October 14-18, 2006, Oslo, Norway [doi>10.1145/1182475.1182506]
• 24: James Lin , Mark W. Newman , Jason I. Hong , James A. Landay, DENIM: finding a tighter fit between tools and practice for Web site design, Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems, p.510-517, April 01-06, 2000, The Hague, The Netherlands [doi>10.1145/332040.332486]
• 25: Linchuan Liu , Peter Khooshabeh, Paper or interactive?: a study of prototyping techniques for ubiquitous computing environments, CHI '03 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems, April 05-10, 2003, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, USA [doi>10.1145/765891.766132]
• 26: Jonas Lwgren , Erik Stolterman, Thoughtful Interaction Design: A Design Perspective on Information Technology, The MIT Press, 2004
• 27: Blair MacIntyre , Maribeth Gandy , Steven Dow , Jay David Bolter, DART: a toolkit for rapid design exploration of augmented reality experiences, Proceedings of the 17th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology, October 24-27, 2004, Santa Fe, NM, USA [doi>10.1145/1029632.1029669]
• 28: Michael McCurdy , Christopher Connors , Guy Pyrzak , Bob Kanefsky , Alonso Vera, Breaking the fidelity barrier: an examination of our current characterization of prototypes and an example of a mixed-fidelity success, Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human Factors in computing systems, April 22-27, 2006, Montréal, Québec, Canada [doi>10.1145/1124772.1124959]
• 29: John M. Carroll , Thomas P. Moran, Design Rationale: Concepts, Techniques, and Use, L. Erlbaum Associates Inc., Hillsdale, NJ, 1996
• 30: Michael J. Muller, Layered participatory analysis: new developments in the CARD technique, Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems, p.90-97, March 2001, Seattle, Washington, United States [doi>10.1145/365024.365054]
• 31: Tek-Jin Nam , Woohun Lee, Integrating hardware and software: augmented reality based prototyping method for digital products, CHI '03 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems, April 05-10, 2003, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, USA [doi>10.1145/765891.766092]
• 32: Celine Pering, Interaction design prototyping of communicator devices: towards meeting the hardware-software challenge, interactions, v.9 n.6, p.36-46, November + December 2002 [doi>10.1145/581951.581952]
• 33: Peter Reichl , Peter Froehlich , Lynne Baillie , Raimung Schatz , Antitza Dantcheva, The LiLiPUT prototype: a wearable lab environment for user tests of mobile telecommunication applications, CHI '07 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems, April 28-May 03, 2007, San Jose, CA, USA [doi>10.1145/1240866.1240907]
• 34: Marc Rettig, Prototyping for tiny fingers, Communications of the ACM, v.37 n.4, p.21-27, April 1994 [doi>10.1145/175276.175288]
• 35: Jim Rudd , Ken Stern , Scott Isensee, Low vs. high-fidelity prototyping debate, interactions, v.3 n.1, p.76-85, Jan. 1996 [doi>10.1145/223500.223514]
• 36: Kurt Schneider, Prototypes as assets, not toys: why and how to extract knowledge from prototypes, Proceedings of the 18th international conference on Software engineering, p.522-531, March 25-29, 1996, Berlin, Germany
• 37: Schön D. A. 1982. The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action. Harper Collins, New York, NY.
• 38: Schön D. A. 1987. Educating the Reflective Practitioner: Toward a New Design for Teaching and Learning in the Professions, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.
• 39: Reinhard Sefelin , Manfred Tscheligi , Verena Giller, Paper prototyping - what is it good for?: a comparison of paper- and computer-based low-fidelity prototyping, CHI '03 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems, April 05-10, 2003, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, USA [doi>10.1145/765891.765986]
• 40: Skog, D. and Söderlund, M. 1999. Virtual information representation. In Proceedings of the 22nd Information Systems Research Seminar in Scandinavia, Keuruu, Finland.
• 41: Snyder, C. 2003. Paper Prototyping: The Fast and Easy Way to Define and Refine User Interfaces. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, San Francisco, CA.
• 42: Jared Spool , Will Schroeder, Testing web sites: five users is nowhere near enough, CHI '01 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems, March 31-April 05, 2001, Seattle, Washington [doi>10.1145/634067.634236]
• 43: Dag Svanaes , Gry Seland, Putting the users center stage: role playing and low-fi prototyping enable end users to design mobile systems, Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems, p.479-486, April 24-29, 2004, Vienna, Austria [doi>10.1145/985692.985753]
• 44: Michael Thompson , Nina Wishbow, Prototyping: tools and techniques: improving software and documentation quality through rapid prototyping, Proceedings of the 10th annual international conference on Systems documentation, p.191-199, October 13-16, 1992, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada [doi>10.1145/147001.147030]
• 45: Jenifer Tidwell, Designing Interfaces, O'Reilly Media, Inc., 2005
• 46: Shmuel Tyszberowicz , Amiram Yehudai, OBSERV—a prototyping language and environment, ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology (TOSEM), v.1 n.3, p.269-309, July 1992 [doi>10.1145/131736.131751]
• 47: Douglas K. Van Duyne , James Landay , Jason I. Hong, The Design of Sites: Patterns, Principles, and Processes for Crafting a Customer-Centered Web Experience, Addison-Wesley Longman Publishing Co., Inc., Boston, MA, 2002
• 48: Van Leeuwen, C., Verstijnen, I. and Hekkert, P. 1999. Common unconscious dynamics underlie common conscious effects: A case study in the interactive nature of perception and creation. In Modeling Consciousness Across the Disciplines, S. Jordan, Ed. University Press of America, Lanham, MD.
• 49: Robert A. Virzi , Jeffrey L. Sokolov , Demetrios Karis, Usability problem identification using both low- and high-fidelity prototypes, Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems: common ground, p.236-243, April 13-18, 1996, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada [doi>10.1145/238386.238516]
• 50: Walkers, M., Takayama, L., and Landay, J. 2002. High-fidelity or low-fidelity paper or computer medium? In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 46th Annual Meeting (HFES'02). 661--665.
• 51: Yin Yin Wong, Rough and ready prototypes: lessons from graphic design, Posters and short talks of the 1992 SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems, May 03-07, 1992, Monterey, California [doi>10.1145/1125021.1125094]
• 52: L. Zucconi , G. Mack , L. G. Williams, Using object-oriented development for support prototyping, Proceedings of the 12th international conference on Software engineering, p.129-132, March 26-30, 1990, Nice, France

INDEX TERMS

Primary Classification:
  H. Information Systems
  H.5 INFORMATION INTERFACES AND PRESENTATION (I.7)
      H.5.2 User Interfaces (D.2.2, H.1.2, I.3.6)

Additional Classification:
  H. Information Systems
  H.1 MODELS AND PRINCIPLES
      H.1.2 User/Machine Systems

General Terms:
Design, Theory

Keywords:
Prototype, design, design space, human-computer interaction, prototyping